基于响应面法的高导热固井材料多目标优化与性能研究

Multi-objective optimization and performance of high thermal conductivity cementing materials based on response surface methodology

  • 摘要:
    目的 地热能作为全球能源结构低碳转型的战略性清洁能源,其高效开发利用对早日达成“双碳”目标至关重要。在地热资源开发中,固井结构的导热性能决定着地热由岩层向地热井套管的传输效率,成为地热资源高效开采的关键影响因素。因此,研发高导热固井材料可为地热资源高效开发提供重要支撑。
    方法 以水胶比、石墨掺量、铁粉掺量、碳化硅掺量与石英砂掺量为主要试验因素,采用正交试验确定对高导热固井材料导热性能影响最显著的3个因素。进一步通过响应面法(RSM)设计3因素3水平响应面试验,建立以导热系数、抗压强度、流动度为响应值的回归模型,分析各因素及其交互作用对高导热固井材料性能的影响,最终通过多目标优化确定高导热固井材料的最优配比。
    结果和结论 各因素对高导热固井材料导热系数的影响程度由高到低依次为石墨掺量(10%)、水胶比(0.57)、铁粉掺量(30%)、石英砂掺量(30%)、碳化硅掺量(10%)。通过RSM构建以水胶比、石墨掺量、铁粉掺量为自变量,导热系数、抗压强度、流动度为响应目标的回归模型,其拟合值R2分别为0.986 7、0.984 8、0.973 7,表明模型可靠性高。RSM方差分析结果表明石墨掺量、水胶比、铁粉掺量对导热系数的影响极显著(P<0.01),水胶比与石墨掺量、水胶比与铁粉掺量交互项对导热系数影响显著(P<0.05);水胶比对抗压强度影响极显著,石墨掺量、铁粉掺量、水胶比与石墨掺量交互项对抗压强度的影响显著;水胶比与石墨掺量对流动度的影响极显著。采用多目标优化法得到的高导热固井材料的最优配比为水胶比0.573、石墨掺量9.95%、铁粉掺量28.62%,对应导热系数、抗压强度及流动度预测值与试验结果误差小于5%,分别为3.237 W/(m·K)、16.77 MPa、21.5 cm,该优化配比及模型为地热井高导热固井材料的工程应用提供了可靠依据。

     

    Abstract:
    Purpose Geothermal energy, as a strategic clean energy for the global energy structure's low-carbon transformation, plays a critical role in achieving the "double carbon" goals. In geothermal resource development, the thermal conductivity of cementing structures determines the heat transfer efficiency from rock formations to the outer casing of geothermal wells, making it a key factor influencing efficient geothermal extraction. Therefore, the development of high thermal conductivity cementing materials can provide essential support for the efficient exploitation of geothermal resources.
    Method Taking water-cement ratio, graphite content, iron powder content, silicon carbide content, and quartz sand content as the main experimental factors, orthogonal experiments were conducted to identify the 3 most significant factors affecting the thermal conductivity performance of high thermal conductivity cementing materials. Further, a 3-factor and 3-level response surface experiment was designed using Response Surface Methodology (RSM) to establish a regression model with thermal conductivity, compressive strength, and flowability as response values. The effects of each factor and their interaction effects on the performance of high thermal conductivity cementing materials were analyzed, and finally, the optimal mix proportion of such materials was determined through multi-objective optimization.
    Results and Discussion  Orthogonal test results indicated that the factors influencing thermal conductivity in descending order of significance and their optimal levels were: graphite content (10%), water-cement ratio (0.57), iron powder content (30%), quartz sand content (30%), and silicon carbide content (10%). A quadratic polynomial regression model was constructed using RSM, with water-cement ratio, graphite content, and iron powder content as variables and thermal conductivity, compressive strength, and flowability as objectives. The coefficients of determination R2were 98.67%, 98.48%, and 97.37%, respectively, demonstrating high model reliability. ANOVA results from RSM showed that graphite content, water-cement ratio, and iron powder content had extremely significant effects on thermal conductivity (P<0.01), while interactions between water-cement ratio and graphite content, and water-cement ratio and iron powder content were significant (P<0.05). Water-cement ratio had an extremely significant effect on compressive strength, with graphite content, iron powder content, and the water-cement ratio-graphite content interaction also showing significant impacts. Water-cement ratio and graphite content had extremely significant effects on flowability. Multi-objective optimization yielded an optimal mix of water-cement ratio 0.573, graphite content 9.95%, and iron powder content 28.62%, with predicted values of thermal conductivity (3.237 W/(m·K)), compressive strength (16.77 MPa), and flowability (21.5 cm). The errors between predicted and laboratory-verified results were less than 5%. Consequently, the proposed model and optimal proportion offer a robust foundation for the practical application of high thermal conductivity cementing materials in geothermal engineering.

     

/

返回文章
返回